Hospital Official Slams D.C. EMS Over 2-Year-Old's Death

Posted: Wednesday, March 10, 2010
Updated: March 11th, 2010 09:50 AM EDT
Enlarge Article Text Reduce Article Text Print Article Email this Article to a Friend

Hospital Official Slams D.C. EMS Over 2-Year-Old's Death






EMS Podcasts
The EMS Squadcast
The EMS Squadcast is a new podcast series dedicated to discussions relevant to the world of EMS today. This month: The RSI controversy and Haiti earthquake response.

Open Airways: Stories from the back of the ambulance
EMS responders share some of the most meaningful cases of their careers, sometimes with humor and always with compassion. We hope that they will help us improve your practice and inspire a new generation of caregivers.


More on EMSResponder.com
Discuss today's top stories, the latest trends and techniques and more, including ALS & BLS topics.

From clinical care to EMS Life, the top emergency medical service education & feature content.

EMS Magazine is the most authoritative printed source for clinical and educational material designed to improve the delivery of prehospital emergency medical care.

BY DAVE STATTER
Courtesy of WUSA-TV

  • Read more at STATter 911 Blog

    WASHINGTON, D.C. -- As the investigation into the death of Stephanie Stephens continues, a top official at Children's National Medical Center has made his views about the case known. In a letter to the editor in The Washington Post, Dr. Joseph Wright said, "The decision not to immediately transport a 2-year-old with respiratory symptoms is inexcusable."

    Dr. Wright is referring the crew from Medic 33 who did not take the little girl to the hospital after her mother's first call to 911 on the morning of February 10. It wasn't until another 911 call, about 9-hours later, that a different crew from Medic 33 took the girl to Children's. She died the next day. The family told 9NEWS NOW Stephanie had pneumonia.

    Dr. Wright, a senior vice president, pediatric emergency physician and director of EMS at the hospital, pointed out in his letter that he believes the city has made little progress since the controversy surrounding the inadequate care provided to dying former New York Times reporter David Rosenbaum. Wright wrote to the Post, "It was only a matter of time before a pediatric Rosenbaum case surfaced."

    According to Dr. Wright's biography, he is a founding director of the hospital's Institute for Prehospital Pediatrics and Emergency Research and "provides state-level leadership as the EMS Medical Director for Pediatrics within the Maryland Institute for Emergency Medical Services Systems". Wright is also a senior investigator and medical director with "the federally-funded Emergency Medical Services for Children National Resource Center."

    DC Fire & EMS Department spokesman Pete Piringer disputes Dr. Wright's claims. In an email to 9NEWS NOW Piringer said, "During the past few years significant progress has been made in many areas concerning the state of EMS in the District of Columbia."

    Piringer points to the implementation of the large majority of the goals from the task force ordered by Mayor Adrian Fenty to provide a blueprint for the future of EMS following Rosenbaum's death in 2006. According to Piringer, "As of today, the Department has completed 39 of those 50 action items, most well ahead of schedule, and is making substantial progress on completing the remaining 11 items."

    Chief Dennis Rubin headed the the task force. Rubin is about to celebrate his third anniversary as head of the DC Fire & EMS Department. Critics, like Kenneth Lyons, president of the union representing civilian EMS workers, point out that Chief Rubin is now in search of his third medical director and is on his fourth set of people to lead EMS training. Lyons calls the lack of continuity "schizophrenic".

    While Lyons believes Dr. Wright is premature in judging the EMS crew in the Stephens case, he concurs with Wright's claims there are problems in providing pre-hospital care to children. In his letter Wright said, "I have stated often for the public record before the D.C. Council Committee on Public Safety and the Judiciary just how little attention D.C. Fire and EMS has paid to preparing its workforce in the care of children."

    Lyons tells 9NEWS NOW that Dr. Wright has long been an advocate for improved training and protocols in dealing with children who are ill or injured and has offered to assist the city in making these improvements.

    The public relations staff at Children's National Medical Center was unable to schedule an interview with Dr. Wright on Tuesday.

    Republished with permission of WUSA-TV.


  • E-mail This Story Print This Story



    Share your thoughts, advice, opinions, and expertise @ EMSResponder.com

         
    Comments

    Posted by colomedic
    (03/10/10 - 01:35 PM)
    MAYBE A LITTLE PRE EMPTIVE BY THE PHYSICIAN. BUT ANY KID WITH BREATHING PROBLEMS NEEDS TO BE EVALUATED BY A PHYSICIAN. ITS COMMON SENSE. I TAKE EVERY KID TO THE HOSPITAL.



    Posted by JPINFV in Pomona, CA
    (03/10/10 - 01:53 PM)
    Fire based EMS SNAFU
    Isnt this standard operating procedure for the fire department? After all, an AMA gets them back to the recliner quicker than a transport. Hopefully the Rosenbaum estate sues DCFD for failure to deliver on their promised reforms.



    Posted by Tigermedic in Pittsburgh, PA
    (03/11/10 - 12:52 AM)
    Shameful
    I concur with the statement that an AMA gets the crew back to the recliner quicker, however it is not only the Fire Department based crews that this is happening with. More and more I am finding just pour laziness in EMS workers, along with a lack of training. I see this in our own services. The other situation is: was this a true AMA? ("Against Medical Advise") if the parents wanted this child transported, then the child should have been tranported, end of story.



    Posted by JW in Flint, MI
    (03/11/10 - 01:08 AM)
    One Simple Answer
    There is one simple answer to DC FEMS problems. Everyone goes to the hospital. If you are called to the scene, you transport, period. You have already spent the time to go to the scene, transport the patient. Education and training is all on the Paramedics and EMTs. Yes, DC Fire should pay for it and train their personnel, but it is ultimately the individuals fault for any lack of training/education. Kenneth Lyons cannot say his personnel are unable to do their job because no one teaches them how to do their job. They had the initial training and it is all continuing education from there. All states that license EMS personnel state that it is the individuals responsibility for continued training/education and not the company or agency they work for. So DC FEMS personnel need to man up, BLS before they ALS, and transport patients.



    Posted by Steve in NH
    (03/11/10 - 06:51 AM)
    EMS needs to remember children crash quickly. Any kid sick enough to have 911 called should be evaluated in an ED. On the other hand, there is a responsibility of parents to provide care for their children. There are other ways to an ED than by ambulance. Not every person in need of emergency care needs to ride an ambulance to get treatment. But lack & lazy EMS providers should find a new career.



    Posted by Michael in Oklahoma
    (03/11/10 - 09:08 AM)
    This has nothing to do with DC beig a fire based service. From what I have read it appears DC EMS has many internal problems. It seems to me the problem within this scenario is a lack of common sense and street smarts. However, we as readers do not know the full story. Did the parents refuse transport initially or did the crew talk them out of it? If the parents wanted transport then why didnt they take the pt POV instead of waiting 9 hours to call back?





    Email Alerts