Woman Says Florida Hospital Left Knife in Her Head

Posted: Wednesday, January 7, 2009
Updated: January 9th, 2009 04:03 AM EDT
Enlarge Article Text Reduce Article Text Print Article Email this Article to a Friend

Woman Says Florida Hospital Left Knife in Her Head




An X-ray shows a portion of the blade near the woman's jaw.
Photo by IBS/news4jax.com
An X-ray shows a portion of the blade near the woman's jaw.


Open Airways
Open Airways: Stories from the back of the ambulance
EMS responders share some of the most meaningful cases of their careers, sometimes with humor and always with compassion. We hope that they will help us improve your practice and inspire a new generation of caregivers.


More on EMSResponder.com
An inside look into the upcoming issue of EMS Magazine and interview with featured writer.

Discuss today's top stories, the latest trends and techniques and more, including ALS & BLS topics.

From clinical care to EMS Life, the top emergency medical service education & feature content.

Story by news4jax.com

News4jax.com Video: Knife in Woman's Head

JACKSONVILLE, Fla. --

A Jacksonville woman plans to sue Shands-Jacksonville Medical Center after she said part of a knife was left behind in her head.

Three years after a Jacksonville woman was stabbed twice in the head, a portion of the blade remains near her jaw. A good look at an X-ray of Edith McQueen's head reveals an object next to the her jaw bone. That object, according to the woman's attorney, is a piece of a knife from an attack that took place more than three years ago.

"Somehow, someway, the knife was left in her head. She presented to the emergency room for treatment from the stab wounds to the head, and they were simply stitched up and Mrs. McQueen was sent home," said McQueen's attorney, Chad Roberts.

In August of 2005, McQueen was stabbed twice from behind in a random act of violence. According to her discharge papers from the hospital, the woman was treated and released the next day after the stab wound was cleaned and sutured loosely and she was listed in stable but good condition.

"A simple X-ray is comparatively easy, inexpensive and accessible, and you would think that a stab wound would probably justify a $25 or $50 X-ray to make sure no foreign body, either dirt or gravel or some foreign object, remained in the wound site, but apparently that didn't happen," Roberts said.

Roberts said his client ended up going back to Shands because she complained of headaches and was scheduled to have an MRI. That's when they made the discovery through an X-ray that the blade was still inside her head.

When Channel 4 called Shands to find out how the incident could have happened, it released a statement saying, "We will not discuss the particulars of any patient's confidential healthcare services."

Shands said it did not know about the lawsuit until the media contacted them on Tuesday.

Roberts said his client's lawsuit is still in the investigative phase and has yet to be filed. He said he hasn't talked to Shands about removing the blade, but he hopes they will plan to do so.


E-mail This Story Print This Story



Share your thoughts, advice, opinions, and expertise @ EMSResponder.com

     


Email Alerts

Powered by Google